Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendations?

From mud covered tanks to grimy aircraft
Post Reply
User avatar
TechHead
Staff Sergeant
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu May 08, 2014 11:17 pm
Location: Sandwich, Kent, UK

Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendations?

Post by TechHead »

Hi All,

Just a quick question regarding what you use and find the most effective way/products to simulate soot and engine exhaust staining on your model aircraft?

Is there any particular product that stands out over others? I've been looking a the usual suspects, eg: Mig, AK, etc. though any advice much appreciated.

Thanks, :)


Simon
Currently On The Bench/Humbrol Modelling Tray:
Airfix 1:72 Hawker Typhoon
Airfix 1:32 Mini Cooper S

Man Stash:
Airfix 1:72 Spitfire Mk.IXc
Airfix 1:48 Messerschmitt Bf109E-4/E-1
User avatar
Paul
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 12622
Joined: Thu May 23, 2013 4:47 pm
Location: Merseyside, England, UK
Contact:
England

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by Paul »

TechHead wrote:Hi All,

Just a quick question regarding what you use and find the most effective way/products to simulate soot and engine exhaust staining on your model aircraft?

Is there any particular product that stands out over others? I've been looking a the usual suspects, eg: Mig, AK, etc. though any advice much appreciated.

Thanks, :)


Simon
Tamiya smoke airbrushed is what I use. :thumb2:
User avatar
Daishi12
Warrant Officer
Warrant Officer
Posts: 1393
Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2013 9:25 pm
Location: Mountain Ash, South Wales
Wales

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by Daishi12 »

Hi Simon, I have seen a build (not sure where) and the modeller used a 50/50 mix of matt black/red brown for exhaust staining which was dry brushed and that seemed to work quite well from the photos.
W.I.P.

Revell 1/72 P-47M
Airfix 1/72 Bristol F2B Fighter

Technical Consultation for MrsModellor :- Tamiya 1/35 S.A.S. Pink Panther
User avatar
ForbesHutton
Chief Warrant Officer 3
Chief Warrant Officer 3
Posts: 1956
Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2013 9:10 am
Location: To,On,Ca
Scotland

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by ForbesHutton »

I just used Vallejo pigments for the first time on the C2:

Image

Image

It's on the exhaust grill (rear/side of the tank).

It's a dry pigment, I put some on the area, they I used mineral spirits to set it, I and a bit more before it dried.
Image
User avatar
TechHead
Staff Sergeant
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu May 08, 2014 11:17 pm
Location: Sandwich, Kent, UK

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by TechHead »

Paul wrote:
TechHead wrote:Hi All,

Just a quick question regarding what you use and find the most effective way/products to simulate soot and engine exhaust staining on your model aircraft?

Is there any particular product that stands out over others? I've been looking a the usual suspects, eg: Mig, AK, etc. though any advice much appreciated.

Thanks, :)


Simon
Tamiya smoke airbrushed is what I use. :thumb2:
Thanks Paul.

Ah, there lies the problem, I am still an air-brushless modeller. ;)
Currently On The Bench/Humbrol Modelling Tray:
Airfix 1:72 Hawker Typhoon
Airfix 1:32 Mini Cooper S

Man Stash:
Airfix 1:72 Spitfire Mk.IXc
Airfix 1:48 Messerschmitt Bf109E-4/E-1
User avatar
rodrant
Chief Warrant Officer 2
Chief Warrant Officer 2
Posts: 1774
Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2014 9:22 pm
Location: Maia - Portugal
Portugal

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by rodrant »

I use a Tamiya weathering master the 'B' one ...it has snow , soot and rust , to me work ok , but I must admit that you can have other products cheaper in the market that work nicely , and this Tamiya product look like make up , and i suppose that make up could do the job (didn't try it but really is what it seems to me ... :-), also for rust and oil stains I use MIG weathering products . Also you have Tamiya Smoke , it is in their range of acrylics it is X-19 , some guys airbrush it in the model But other more experienced than me may give you some other ideas .
Cheers ,
António

On the Bench
a lot of stuff right now :-)
User avatar
TechHead
Staff Sergeant
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu May 08, 2014 11:17 pm
Location: Sandwich, Kent, UK

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by TechHead »

Daishi12 wrote:Hi Simon, I have seen a build (not sure where) and the modeller used a 50/50 mix of matt black/red brown for exhaust staining which was dry brushed and that seemed to work quite well from the photos.
Thanks. :)

I was contemplating buying the Tamiya weathering (3 colour) kit that included soot, though will hold off and give your recommendation a try.
Currently On The Bench/Humbrol Modelling Tray:
Airfix 1:72 Hawker Typhoon
Airfix 1:32 Mini Cooper S

Man Stash:
Airfix 1:72 Spitfire Mk.IXc
Airfix 1:48 Messerschmitt Bf109E-4/E-1
User avatar
TechHead
Staff Sergeant
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu May 08, 2014 11:17 pm
Location: Sandwich, Kent, UK

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by TechHead »

ForbesHutton wrote:I just used Vallejo pigments for the first time on the C2:

Image

Image

It's on the exhaust grill (rear/side of the tank).

It's a dry pigment, I put some on the area, they I used mineral spirits to set it, I and a bit more before it dried.
Now that looks really nice - great job! As a newbie I was holding off entering the world of pigments, though may have to be brave and venture forth. :)
Currently On The Bench/Humbrol Modelling Tray:
Airfix 1:72 Hawker Typhoon
Airfix 1:32 Mini Cooper S

Man Stash:
Airfix 1:72 Spitfire Mk.IXc
Airfix 1:48 Messerschmitt Bf109E-4/E-1
User avatar
TechHead
Staff Sergeant
Staff Sergeant
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu May 08, 2014 11:17 pm
Location: Sandwich, Kent, UK

Re: Effective Engine Exhaust & Soot - Product Recommendation

Post by TechHead »

rodrant wrote:I use a Tamiya weathering master the 'B' one ...it has snow , soot and rust , to me work ok , but I must admit that you can have other products cheaper in the market that work nicely , and this Tamiya product look like make up , and i suppose that make up could do the job (didn't try it but really is what it seems to me ... :-), also for rust and oil stains I use MIG weathering products . Also you have Tamiya Smoke , it is in their range of acrylics it is X-19 , some guys airbrush it in the model But other more experienced than me may give you some other ideas .
Thanks Antonio, good tips. :)

I was contemplating buying and trying out the Tamiya weather master than contained the soot, though hadn't heard any reports from anyone that had used it. Will try the 50/50 paint method kindly provided in a post earlier in this thread, and failing that (ie: I make a hash of it) I will give the Tamiya product a go.

Cheers,


Simon
Currently On The Bench/Humbrol Modelling Tray:
Airfix 1:72 Hawker Typhoon
Airfix 1:32 Mini Cooper S

Man Stash:
Airfix 1:72 Spitfire Mk.IXc
Airfix 1:48 Messerschmitt Bf109E-4/E-1
Post Reply

Return to “Weathering”