Page 1 of 1

Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 7:55 am
by Twokidsnosleep
I was playing around today, trying to figure how to make a new front axle for a 1/32 Bugatti type 59 I am rebuilding from an e bay glue bomb.
Image
This is a similar version of the T Series of Bugatti racers
Image

Was reading and watching videos about soldering (and brazing) and bought some silver solder today and gave it a whirl
Image
Plastic vs brass axle
Image

Test fit between the wheel...not too bad
Image

If anyone has any soldering tips fire away, I am all ears

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 11:02 am
by Tajfl
My advice is more on the safety area. You shuld try to avoid to breathe the smoke as much as possible. From my experience I can tell you that can be really painful. On a small projects like modeling should not be a big problem, but it is better if you take care of some kind of ventilation ;)

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 4:40 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Great tip, healthy safe working always a good reminder
I have a big window right over my desk with a screened opening...had that open

I was thinking a fire extinguisher as well when there are open flames
Will look for better work base than the wood

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 4:56 pm
by chief5437
Just been building a PE cockpit, so I thought I'd give the soldering a go. I've gotta say, I'm finding it easier than using ca. I don't end up with the parts sticking to me rather than the kit, lol!

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 5:58 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
chief5437 wrote:Just been building a PE cockpit, so I thought I'd give the soldering a go. I've gotta say, I'm finding it easier than using ca. I don't end up with the parts sticking to me rather than the kit, lol!
Absolutely
I had CA glued the three tube bits for the axle with telescoping pins...worked ok, but huge joints and not too strong. That is when I went into the silver solder

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 6:28 pm
by DaveTheMinion
Looking superb mate, the only advice I could give is always clean the contact area, same as plumbing I suppose, a good clean joint is a secure joint, plus I use a glass fibre brush to clean the area before I solder, only ever done a little on trains so no expert, but my train didn't fall apart......

you can also get one of these bad boys ;) I know I want one....

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun May 03, 2015 8:29 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
DaveTheMinion wrote:Looking superb mate, the only advice I could give is always clean the contact area, same as plumbing I suppose, a good clean joint is a secure joint, plus I use a glass fibre brush to clean the area before I solder, only ever done a little on trains so no expert, but my train didn't fall apart......

you can also get one of these bad boys ;) I know I want one....

Whoa, that torch steps things up quickly
I was looking at the resistance soldering tools as well...but will stay low tech for now
Not sure how much of this I will be doing, but yes with silver solder, things are solid and ready to finish right after cooling....much better than the tin soldering that is for electrical bits with no stress joints

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Mon May 04, 2015 3:14 am
by Twokidsnosleep
Some things I did different from electrical soldering
*Used silver solder that increases the silver content in the solder and the strength
*cut the solder into tiny little chips and apply them to the joint where the flux is
* Used thick flux that holds the solder bits around the joint location....so when the metal is heated, poof, the solder just wicks right into the joint
*used a butane torch to get the heat there fast, then off fast

The silver solder sets really hard as well, you can feel the difference from the weak tin stuff. You can finish a silver solder joint right away when cool enough to handle

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Mon May 04, 2015 4:38 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Continuing with the front axle fabrication:
Square brass stock to make two c-shaped linkages for steering and wheel rotation
I drilled the required six small holes before I split the stock into two
Image
Image

Some test assembly with pins
Image

And a mock up with the frame and tire
Image
Lots more to refine and file, but rolling and steering will work now
Next step is to solder a tube to each 'C' arm to accept a wheel

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Tue May 05, 2015 11:50 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Lots of fun soldering the brass rounds onto their supports for the tie rod
Image

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Tue May 12, 2015 11:20 am
by digger303
Twokidsnosleep wrote:Some things I did different from electrical soldering
*Used silver solder that increases the silver content in the solder and the strength
*cut the solder into tiny little chips and apply them to the joint where the flux is
* Used thick flux that holds the solder bits around the joint location....so when the metal is heated, poof, the solder just wicks right into the joint
*used a butane torch to get the heat there fast, then off fast

The silver solder sets really hard as well, you can feel the difference from the weak tin stuff. You can finish a silver solder joint right away when cool enough to handle

the higher the silver content the lower the heat required........go to a trade plumbing supplier

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Tue May 12, 2015 11:50 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
the higher the silver content the lower the heat required........go to a trade plumbing supplier[/quote]


Hmmm, that sounds weird to me :scratch::
Though more silver content means more heat :wtf:

I found a good resource is researching the jewelry trade as they have many vids and products. Seen a high, medium and low temp silver solders. This allows you to have multiple joints with different temp solders so that you don't melt the step you just finished when you add something else, just have to plan ahead.

It is a lot more complex and technique sensitive than I thought....been having trouble soldering some simple tubes for my son's windmill. Darn solider would not flow, just forms into little balls and falls off. Likely surface contamination, flux issue or not heating metal properly.

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 12:56 am
by digger303
[
It is a lot more complex and technique sensitive than I thought....been having trouble soldering some simple tubes for my son's windmill. Darn solider would not flow, just forms into little balls and falls off. Likely surface contamination, flux issue or not heating metal properly.[/quote]

I do a lot of copper and when that happens.Number one reason is pipe not hot enough for solder to flow. second is pipe is dirty
sand the tubes a little assuming the tubs aren't aluminum.

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 2:15 am
by Twokidsnosleep
I would say i did both, Digger
I manhandled the pipe and hit the solder before the metal with the flame
Just gotta walk away sometimes and regroup

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 10:52 am
by digger303
Twokidsnosleep wrote:the higher the silver content the lower the heat required........go to a trade plumbing supplier

Hmmm, that sounds weird to me :scratch::
Though more silver content means more heat :wtf:

I found a good resource is researching the jewelry trade as they have many vids and products. Seen a high, medium and low temp silver solders. This allows you to have multiple joints with different temp solders so that you don't melt the step you just finished when you add something else, just have to plan ahead.

It is a lot more complex and technique sensitive than I thought....been having trouble soldering some simple tubes for my son's windmill. Darn solider would not flow, just forms into little balls and falls off. Likely surface contamination, flux issue or not heating metal properly.[/quote]

Yes you are right....higher silver content the higher the melting point....it does flow better though. :ooops:

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 10:53 am
by digger303
Twokidsnosleep wrote:I would say i did both, Digger
I manhandled the pipe and hit the solder before the metal with the flame
Just gotta walk away sometimes and regroup

seems strange ...what are the tubes made of ?

I always heat the target first before introducing the solder. if the metal is hot enough it should melt and solder almost straight away.

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Thu May 14, 2015 3:56 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
The tubes are finer diameter brass
Stupidly I sent the flame after my solder chips in the flux rather than heating the metal first, boiling the flux and then the solder melts and flows in a millisecond
I watched myself do it wrong twice and then heat the hell out of everything....just stopped shy of a glowing pile of goo
Hence stop, regroup and try another day. Not sure what I was thinking

Because the tubes are small diameter and it is delicate work, I like having the solder chips in the flux and then I have a free hand for holding
But you are right..heat the target metal first

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 1:02 am
by digger303
One thing I have found is if you place target on a lump of thickish steel and pre heat it a little ( have to be careful...self harm) working time is extended a little, any additional heat applied is small when making adjustments and you can bounce the flame off it so as to not melt the delicate tubing.
ALSO you can make use of the different melting points of the solder(different ag content) as you make progressive joints on the one piece....jewelers do that a lot.

Of course depends on equipment available to you as well

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Fri May 15, 2015 1:15 am
by Twokidsnosleep
Cool, I appreciate the expert input

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 7:43 am
by Twokidsnosleep
This was my "Friday after a stressful workday before dinner is ready blowing off steam" project
Formed a piece of brass to create the cowling shape for the front of the Bugatti's cockpit. See brass section vs the blue body
Then silver soldered brass cowling to a flat sheet of brass to create a firewall.
I failed miserably at this a couple weeks ago, so took another run at it
Image
Flux applied with a syringe so it is more accurate
Image


This is the cowling sitting on the flat piece held in place by magnets and a heavy bending tool...so nothing's moving
Torch flame goes in that front opening where flux and solder await along the perfect joint formed by this jig
Image

Cowling and firewall semi polished and shaped
Image

I don't know if I am making a whole brass Bugatti or not yet....just practicing soldering with the purpose of making parts for something at this point that may or may not later be assembled together to form a sort of carish vehicle looking object somewhat resembling a T59 Bugatti :think:
That is practice with a purpose rather than random shapes just soldered together :geek:

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 7:56 am
by digger303
looks very professional soldering an jointing

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 8:14 am
by Twokidsnosleep
Thanks Mate, that is a very kind thing to say :cheers2:
I am still a complete spaz at it though, but getting better bit by bit
Lots of thought has to go into planning joints out, drilling holes first and then a good jig to hold everything together

You made the great suggestion for a metal work surface and that steel works well....and acts as a heat sink too
I have a ceramic tile that I will use under all my soldering efforts from now on

I really appreciate your help, thank you :thumb2:

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 9:45 am
by digger303
No problems.
One more... be care putting open flame for extened periods in one spot. The glaze may ( happens rarely) fly off the tile and in your eye.

Good jig you made up for holding the bits. the Magnets work well.....very adjustable. :th:

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 4:07 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Ahh ok, I won't be hitting the tile with any flame, but never hurts to be warned
The large tile I have will be used as the base below my little metal work surface ....just so I don't burn the desk and modelling mat with heat transfer through the metal work surface.
BUT I will be careful with that

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2015 11:18 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
rubegoldberg wrote:sweet!

scott going all og. love it.

i'm curious though… do they not make fluxcore solder for silver soldering? that would be a lot easier than manually applying a paste flux. i think you already know this, but in any form of gas welding, braising, or soldering the key is to heat the base metal first. ideally the base metal will melt the filler for you.
Og.??? No comprendo muchacho
Yes you are right they make flux core solder
Your parts have to fit perfectly, no gaps and the flame/heat will displace loose parts. the flux is a paste, so holds the solder right where i want it

My problems are control, placement and stability
To control the solder, precision flux lets me have solder just where I want it and it etches the brass and solder only stick to this area, not that hard to apply flux especially with small parts.
By placing small chips of solder into the flux I minimize flash and get it right where I want it, especially in complex and small shapes. I apply it from the roll as you described above
Using jigs, magnets, clamps etc stabilize the work piece and frees up my hands to hold something still for support
I am still learning and there is a long curve to master it

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2015 6:00 am
by Twokidsnosleep
I am so white-bread, sorry

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2015 7:23 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Fooling around with bending more body parts. Finger bending the hood....made a paper form and then cut brass with shears. Lots more refinement to go for a good fit. That is my 'new' tile base to work on
Nothing is soldered in place, just dry fit testing to try and get gaps closed...it isn't easy to do that!!!
Image
Image

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Sun Jun 14, 2015 7:29 am
by Twokidsnosleep
Frame rails cut and laid out
Image

Soldered front extensions
Image

Soldered rear extensions
Image

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 8:22 pm
by Tajfl
Nice :)
From front axle, to maybe whole brass model ;)

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 9:45 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Tajfl wrote:Nice :)
From front axle, to maybe whole brass model ;)

Yes, I am a complete idiot :wall:

Re: Anyone doing brass and silver solder??

Posted: Wed Jun 24, 2015 5:16 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Working off some plans now
Image

Image

More parts. Floor pan, oil cooler, a rear leaf spring and it's mounting rodImage
Image

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Fri Jun 26, 2015 7:48 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Hey thanks man, I appreciated the feedback...been quiet on my threads lately :tw:

This is a little sideline pet project and I am actually getting better at soldering, which is what this project is all about
The real issue is setting parts up squarely with tight joints and stable enough to solder..that is the time killer :wall:
Also lots of time researching parts and their design and trying to duplicate those. Blueprints are hard to find.
I am happy with the rear spring"s soldering, but not its appearance or function...so will make a few more
It is kinda cool to make your own parts

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Fri Jun 26, 2015 8:46 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
Absolutely...pricey, but absolutely. Magnets work wonders as well

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Mon Jul 06, 2015 6:45 am
by Twokidsnosleep
Some more body parts made today
Midline seam re-created with brass tube, made other rear spring and got the windscreen cowling soldered to its location.
Image

Image

Image
The midline has been located properly, just looks off as the panel sides have uneven extra brass beyond their finish lines....ie the sides aren't the same length yet.

I want to get the frame rails soldered together, but have to figure out some complicated maneuvers with a jig to keep them square :scratch::
Been contemplating louvre manufacture as well, will likely be plastic add one as cannot do it predictably by hand
:cheers2:

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Mon Jul 06, 2015 9:34 am
by digger303
going well

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Mon Jul 06, 2015 2:35 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
digger303 wrote:going well

Thanks mate
Slow, but ok.
Haven't had a major soldering disaster recently and added that wind cowling to the cockpit area that was giving me fits!

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Mon Jul 06, 2015 3:32 pm
by digger303
you have more courage than I to attempt that little project.

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Mon Jul 20, 2015 6:31 am
by Twokidsnosleep
My little brass pet project (and all the others) is all packed up and tucked away safe for an upcoming move
Hope to get back to it in a few weeks
:cheers2:

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:10 pm
by NoelSmith
Very Impressive Model Engineering in such a small scale.
Where did you source the radially spoked PE wheels?

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:31 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
NoelSmith wrote: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:10 pm Very Impressive Model Engineering in such a small scale.
Where did you source the radially spoked PE wheels?
My god I haven't thought about this in ages
Not sure where those wheels were from will have to look that up on my old ipad at home
The project died as I could not figure out how to do the vent louvres for the engine cowl symmetrical and perfect
Hmm maybe some 3D printed inserts :think:

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 4:23 pm
by MrBowcat
Image

:D

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 5:21 pm
by Twokidsnosleep
MrBowcat wrote: Wed Jan 04, 2023 4:23 pm Image

:D
hey wasn't me
2014/15 is when I started posting in ISM :think:

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 8:53 pm
by ForeverPlasticKits
Trying to recreate an axle you rebuild the full model ... THIS HUGE AND AWESOME, i love this post! :thumb1: :thumb2:

Re: Learning brass construction with silver solder

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 9:55 pm
by digger303
Twokidsnosleep wrote: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:31 pm
NoelSmith wrote: Tue Jan 03, 2023 8:10 pm Very Impressive Model Engineering in such a small scale.
Where did you source the radially spoked PE wheels?
My god I haven't thought about this in ages
Not sure where those wheels were from will have to look that up on my old ipad at home
The project died as I could not figure out how to do the vent louvres for the engine cowl symmetrical and perfect
Hmm maybe some 3D printed inserts :think:
A cnc machine or laser cutter to cut the slots and then a piece of metal slightly shorter in length to press the vent gently into shape.
:cheers2: